Viper Lair
Sponsor
Menu
Latest Stuff
LH ADS #1

 

Latest Stuff
PC Power & Cooling Silencer 750 Quad
OCZ Rally2 4GB
MSI P7N SLI
Gigabyte 8800 GT
AMD Phenom X3 8750 Triple Core
Hitachi Deskstar 500GB
Cooler Master CM690
MSI X48 Platinum
Patriot DDR3-15000 2GB Kit
MSI K9A2 Platinum 790FX
Latest Stuff
LH ADS #2
Search for lowest prices:


for 


Price Search:    for    

Center AD #2
Crucial Ballistix PC2-5300 Crucial Ballistix PC2-5300: Crucial has officially released some new memory modules today. We look at their new PC2-5300 kit.
Date: August 3, 2005
Manufacturer: Crucial Technology
Written By: David Pankhurst
Price: $211 USD

    What do the results show for us in this test?  This test seems to favor faster memory as moving to DDRII seems to provide a 4.5% increase in render speed and also is more efficient than the DDRI memory.  Moving to higher speeds we see a increase that is smaller than the increase in clock speed, showing higher DDRII speeds aren't as needed here.  Lets move to our other tests.

Other Tests

    First lets look at a complete office test, in Sysmark 2004.  While it does go through a very comprehensive test suite, I would like to see it move away from a score and rather look at time to complete tasks instead.  However it is still useful, so lets see if DDRII makes a difference.

Sysmark 2004: ECS 915P-A DDRI: ECS 915P-A DDRII: Asus P5LD2-Deluxe DDRII: Asus P5LD2-Deluxe DDRII (700MHz):
3D: 178 179 176 182
2D: 196 199 202 214
Web: 159 161 155 162
Content: 113 109 104 104
Data: 154 160 159 166
Data Arranging: 134 138 139 142
Overall Internet: 177 179 177 186
Overall Office Productivity: 133 135 134 137
Overall: 155 157 155 161

    Again there isn't alot of difference between DDRI and DDRII memory in this test, in fact two points seperate them in the overall scores.  The biggest increases for DDRII was in the Data and Data Arranging, which can be considered memory intensive areas, with a 3-4% increase resulting here.  Overclocking results in higher scores overall but is basically because of the increase in clock speed.  The biggest increase in this test is a 6% increase in the 2D portion of the test which is very slightly better than the clock speed increase.  Lets see if games can show the results that the memory benchmarks said existed.

    First is Half Life 2, a graphically nice game that takes advantage of system resources.  So lets see if bandwidth increases show any discernable difference.

    Interesting results from this test.  Moving to DDRII gives a 5% increase in frame rate in this non GPU limited test.  However overclocking the RAM doesn't show the same improvement, as the difference is 4.5%, less that the CPU speed increase, though some may be attributed to the RAM.  Can UT2004 show more of a difference?

    Again the move to DDRII nets a performance boost of 3% which is a small but real difference in this game.  Overclocking the RAM gives us the same result as Half Life 2, a 4.5% increase in frame rate.  So the games did show an increase because of DDRII but increasing the bandwidth beyond that point provides little in return.  The results are much like that of ScienceMarks' Membench test.

Conclusion

    We've seen the RAM, seen its performance, and seen its overclockability, so what can we conclude?

    The packaging of this RAM isn't anything to take your breath away, as it follows Crucial's minimalist thinking while still protecting the memory.  The actual sticks of RAM aren't in the same packaging inside the box, which is more of a small aesthetic touch than anything else.  Otherwise the RAM is covered in a gold colored aluminum heatsink, which does get rather warm when in use.

    Overclocking was adequate with the RAM going to its rated speed of 667MHz at low timings, but only making it up to 700MHz at most, though it did it at the same timings.  Whether this is a matter of the motherboard not being able to go faster we will see soon, but still the results were okay for this RAM.

    Performance takes a few forms.  If your are a fan of synthetic memory tests than this RAM is significantly better that DDRI and overclocking helps quite a bit.  However most of us don't run these tests continuously so we look to the real world results.  For the most part there is no significant increase due to DDRII memory.  The exceptions are TMPGEnc which shows a 4.5% increase by moving to DDRII, and the game tests which show a 3-5% increase in frame rate (3-4fps) also by moving to DDRII. 

    Price is always an issue and Crucial usually provides a very reasonable price on their RAM, regardless of the type.  Its main competitor is that of Corsair's PC25400UL kit, but that retails for above $250 (US) at the time of writing.  Crucial's kit as reviewed retails for about $211 (US) which is significantly cheaper and is backed by their great warranty.

Pros: Low latency, lifetime warranty, decent performance, well priced.

Cons: Average overclocker which was reflected in the performance.

Bottom Line: This is a solid memory kit that provides low latency at higher clock speeds.  The only downside is that the higher clock speeds don't do much on their own so overclocking the CPU is needed here.

If you have any comments, be sure to hit us up in our forums.

HOME

Copyright © 2001-2006 Viper Lair. All Rights Reserved.

AMD CPU'S
ALL AMD CPU'S
Athlon AM2
Athlon 64 X2
Intel CPU'S
ALL Intel CPU's
Core 2 Duo
Pentium D
Pentium4
ATI Video Cards
All-In-Wonder
All Radeons
TV Wonder
NVIDIA Cards
7900 GTX
7950 GX2
7900 GT
Memory
Corsair DDR2
Kingston DDR2
Crucial DDR2
OCZ DDR2
Announcement