Corsair
has a reputation among enthusiasts as makers of some of the best
ram in the business. Over the years, as ram technologies change,
as well as getting faster, Corsair was always out there, putting
out products to meet the demands of power users.
While
DDR2 has been something of a hard sell for many users, it has
steadily, albeit slowly, gaining acceptance among enthusiasts.
With AMD slated to possibly offer DDR2 with their next-gen platform,
things are looking up for the oft maligned ram format.
Now,
whether you need DDR2 or plan a Pentium 4 (only 915P chipsets
and up currently supports DDR2) is one decision you need to make.
The second is how much of it? In our opinion, 512MB is the true
minimum we consider for Windows XP, and 1GB the recommended. We've
seen reports about 2GB making a bigger impact, but we feel this
is something worth looking into first hand.

Today
we'll be checking out Corsair's TWIN2X2048-6400 PRO kit.
These modules are based on the XMS2 line, and feature a platinum
coloured heat spreader and the same activity LEDs that we're familiar
with in their Pro Series modules.
Specifications
|
Part
Number
|
Speed
|
Size
|
Package
|
CAS
Latency
|
|
|
XMS2-6400
|
2GB
|
2x240
DIMM
|
5-5-5-12-T1
|
You can view the full specifications in this PDF,
but what you need to know is the modules are validated with multiple
Intel based motherboards at 800MHz.
The
ram modules arrived in a hard plastic case, with each ram module
fitted in the clear plastic shell. It's worth pointing this out
is because there should be no confusion in what you're getting.
You have a clear view of the ram, and the labels (indicating the
type of modules), and the packaging is snap sealed. The seal changes
to a slightly translucent white when opened, so it should be pretty
obvious to the buyer if the package has been tampered with.
The
XMS2 Pro Series modules have platinum coloured heat spreaders.
Along with improving the cooling of the ram, the spreaders (from
what I was also told by a marketing rep) will reduce EMI since
it shields the ram, but I don't have any quantitative proof of
that.
The
kit is rated at PC2-6400, which works out to 800MHz. The ram timings
are a little high, 5-5-5-12, and as many enthusiasts know, tighter
timings normally result in better performance. However, as memory
speeds increase, it is extremely difficult to maintain stability
with such low timings and lately we've noticed that the timings
seem to be having a lesser effect on performance as memory speeds
increase.
All
of the TWINX kits are tested in pairs and in a Dual Channel environment,
which all of Intel's new chipsets (including offerings from VIA,
NVIDIA and ATI) support. All the Pro Series XMS2 modules feature
the same activity LEDs that makes this line of ram so popular.
There are 24 LEDs present, and they light up as the ram is being
used. They do look nice, and it's interesting to see how hard
the ram is being pushed in a particular application, but they
don't offer any actual troubleshooting use as the XPERT series
do. I suppose if you turn on your PC, and they don't light up
at all, you'll know you have a problem somewhere.
Overclocking

A RAM
Stress Test Professional (R.S.T.) Pro2 card will be used to
test for reliability as well as stability during our overclocking
tests. The card is quite expensive, but if you're testing a lot
of ram, or you're a technician troubleshooting systems, this card
is well worth the money.
How it works is that the R.S.T. Pro2 goes into
a free PCI slot and after POST, it bypasses the OS completely,
loading a proprietary OS and software package (embedded on the
card itself). The card allows you to perform stress and performance
benchmarks without the Operating System's memory footprint, memory
resident programs, or drivers interfering with the memory installed.
We'll provide a full review in the future, but that is the gist
of it.
We proceeded with overclocking, and tested the ram
via the memory tests on the R.S.T. Pro2 until we got a failure.
At DDR2 800, the Koolance EXOS cooled ASUS P5WD2 Premium and P4
560 (3.6GHz) ES handled the TWIN2X2048 without any problems, so
we're off to a good start since this is the rated speed.
Setting the ram speed at Auto, we then proceeded
to crank up the FSB until we failed to POST. This occurred at
788MHz, though we were not able to get into Windows until we dropped
down to 776MHz. We reinstalled the R.S.T. Pro2 card, and had some
problems passing the memory tests at this speed. After bumping
the memory voltage a bit higher (2.2v), the memory passed the
test.
We should point out that at 776MHz, we were not
able to reach anywhere near the ram's maximum rated speed of 800MHz.
Since we do have an ES (Engineering Sample) Pentium 4, we fooled
around a bit with the multiplier and FSB, and set the memory at
a 1:2. With these settings, we settled on 914MHz as a maximum,
stable overclock.
In terms of memory timings, the ram was pretty much
dead set on 5-5-5-12 at all overclocked settings. At 800MHz, we
were able to tweak the timings to 4-4-4-10, and pass the R.S.T.
Pro2 tests.
Test
Setup
ASUS
P5WD2 Premium: Intel P4 560, Pentium 4 840 Extreme Edition, 2
x 1024MB Corsair TWIN2X PC6400 Pro, ATI X850 PE, 160GB Seagate
SATA 7200rpm, Windows XP SP1.
The testing configurations will be as follows: Stock (800 @ 5-5-5-12)
, OC = Overclocked (914 @ 5-5-5-12) and TW = Tweaked (800 @ 4-4-4-10).
The comparison memory will be Crucial's Ballistix 6400 (review
forthcoming) run at stock speeds. The Crucial kit is a 1GB kit
that I picked up recently and the point of including it here is
to illustrate improvements (if there are any) from moving to 2GB
from 1GB. We will also be altering CPUs during the tests depending
on the application needs.
SiSoft Sandra 2005 Memory w/P4 560

Obviously, tweaking the memory timings have a positive
affect on system performance, though not as much as sheer overclocking.
There are minimal differences between the Crucial and Corsair
parts, despite Corsair having a 1GB edge on the kit. These results
are synthetic though, so let's look at real-world scenarios.
Battlefield 2 w/P4 560

Corsair recently published a document showing off
the need for 2GB of ram in certain games. While we didn't match
their numbers, there is a tangible difference moving up in ram
for Battlefield 2. This game is simply ram hungry, so the more
the merrier. How about another game?
Unreal Tournament 2004 Fastest w/P4 560

UT2004 doesn't seem to need the extra ram all that
much, and benefits much more from faster ram. Luckily, the Corsair
TWIN2X2048-6400 PRO overclocks quite well, and does a good job
speeding up the framerates.